RUBRIC
Global Health Care Critique Presentation
Criteria Excellent Work Meets Expectation Needs Improvement Total
Points Introduction
Up to 10 points
Provides an introduction to the
topic of the presentation.
Explains the significance and
rationale for the presentation
Minimally compliant with
guidelines.
Non-compliant with guidelines.
Performs a
comprehensive
analysis of the video.
Up to 30 points
Presentation covers all required
material for the assignment
(including integration of any
required resources). Analysis,
logic, and critical thinking are
effective and complete,
demonstrating depth, clarity,
and understanding.
Presentation covers most
required material for the
assignment (including
integration of any required
resources). Analysis, logic, and
critical thinking are mostly
effective and complete.
Presentation covers some required
material for the assignment
(including integration of any
required resources). Analysis,
logic, and critical thinking are
somewhat effective and complete.
Utilizes a
comprehensive
review and analysis
of the different
policies presented as
it relates to the
Nursing Profession
Up to 20 points
Presentation of relevant
information that clearly
supports a central purpose or
argument and shows a
thoughtful, in-depth analysis of
the different policies as it
relates to the Nursing
Profession.
Information provided a
reasonable support for a central
purpose or argument and
displays evidence of a basic
analysis of the different policies
as it relates to the Nursing
Profession
Information supports a central
purpose or argument at times.
Analysis is basic or general.
Organization and
clarity of presentation
Up to 10 points
Structure and flow of
presentation is clear. Ideas are
effectively introduced,
developed, and concluded.
Structure and flow of
presentation is adequate, but
components may not be
complete. Ideas are mostly
introduced, developed, and
concluded.
Structure and flow of presentation
needs significant work. Major
breakdown between ideas
introduced, developed, and
concluded. Flow of ideas is not
always clear.
Use of proper
grammar, spelling,
punctuation and APA
format
Up to 20 points
Spelling, sentence structure,
grammar, and punctuation are
excellent, and all sources are
properly cited; reference list in
APA format is
Spelling, sentence structure,
Grammar, and punctuation are
adequate, and/or most sources
are properly. Minor APA errors
in the reference list are noted.
Some additional editing would
have been helpful.
Spelling, sentence structure,
grammar, and punctuation are
inconsistent, and/or some sources
are properly cited. Multiple APA
errors in the reference list are
noted. Significant
Limit of fifteen (15)
slides, duration 20
minutes.
Up to 10 points
Delivery is excellent. Delivery
is clear, concise, and
professional. Presentation is
neither too short nor too long.
Delivery is good. Delivery is
usually clear, concise, and
professional. Presentation is
either too short or too long by
about 10%.
Delivery is fair. Delivery is
somewhat clear, concise, and
professional. Presentation is either
too short or too long by about
20%.